Previous Next 

May 31 2018
BOY Crazy: Inside The Party For THE BOYS IN THE BAND Comments (0)

IMG_5201Playwright Mart Crowley appeared for the final bows
IMG_5201Take a bow — the boys of The Boys in the Band (Images from audience member in mezzanine)

It took The Boys in the Band 50 years to get to Broadway, and it took me nearly as long to get into the pre-opening after-party ... but I did.

Huge Recap of the Original The Boys in the Band — HERE!

I impulsively bought one of the last tickets for Wednesday's 7 p.m. performance (I had already seen the first preview April 30), scoring one with an empty seat on one side of me and two empty seats on the other. (There were only seven empty seats in the house; not surprising since the show's official opening night is tonight, which is probably the night fans targeted, thinking it would be the star-studded choice.)

Boys in the Band marquee gay NYC
Boys in the Band marquee gay NYC
Boys in the Band marquee gay NYCMarquee marks (Images by Matthew Rettenmund)

When I showed up, I stood with Anna Wintour and Marc Jacobs, and spotted numerous recognizables milling around the red carpet, which attracted the likes of Robert Wagner (who along with his late wife Natalie Wood was an early champion of playwright Mart Crowley), Billy Porter, Andy Cohen, Lynn Collins, Ryan Murphy, Allison Williams, Bruce Bozzi, Celia Keenan-Bolger, Paul McGill, Nikki M. James, Miss J. Alexander, Patch Darragh, Mario Cantone, Anthony Rapp, and many more.

Screen Shot 2018-05-31 at 12.18.12 PML-R: Stephen Schwartz; Patti LuPone hugging Christine Ebersole; Anthony Rapp & BF Ken Ithiphol (Images by Matthew Rettenmund)

Making my way in, I spotted Steven Meisel — I was swooning contemplating Madonna's first work with him for Mademoiselle Screen Shot 2018-05-31 at 12.32.27 PM all the way through their Sex book (he later beyond-politely declined a photo request because he'd had an accident and was sporting a shiner) — and then Lena Dunham. Lena was so approachable I couldn't resist asking for a quick selfie in the theater, which she happily submitted to. I also saw, four or five rows up, Patti LuPone greeting Christine Ebersole and also Stephen Schwartz.

Seated in my row was a tourist who slept through the consistently engaging production, and Larry Kramer with his husband, architect David Webster. Larry, who turns 83 next month, loudly protested his malfunctioning earpiece for 10 minutes, but nobody dared complain — I mean, it's Larry Kramer, faggots, and nobody wanted it to be the night we dissed Larry Kramer.

Full Review of The Boys in the Band — HERE

After the play — full review here — I went outside and randomly walked by Tina Fey as she was darting off. She was adorable! I asked for a pic and she was not just indulgent, she was totally, totally happy to do it. Probably one of my all-time favorite performers. I also grabbed (not literally) sexy Adam Rodriguez, who was happy to pose with everyone, as was fellow heartthrob Max Carver.

Screen Shot 2018-05-31 at 12.35.46 PMWith Peter White, 80, and Laurence Luckinbill, 83 (Images by Mike Summers & Matthew Rettenmund)

I bumped into my friends Mike and Domenick outside, and while I missed Robert Wagner (who runs fast for an octogen Imagesarian), I did chat with Laurence Luckinbill, who was there with his wife, the fab Lucie Arnaz. Larry originated the role of Hank Off-Broadway in 1968 and played it in the 1970 film. He was effusive in his praise for the new production, and for the performance of Tuc Watkins in his old role.

DSC06798Tastes great, less — oh, Mary, don't ask! (Image by Matthew Rettenmund)

Boys in the band PDVD_013Having met up with Larry, I was determined to meet Peter White, who originated the role of Alan. Along with Larry, the's one of only three surviving cast members of the first Boys in the Band, the other being the elusive Reuben Greene, who is apparently living in Philly now and who was not at the show. (Forties movie actor Carleton Carpenter would have been a fun invitee as well; he took over as Michael during the show's original Off-Broadway run.)

DSC06793Peter White and Bill Hutchisons, two Alans separated by 50 years (Image by Matthew Rettenmund)

I went to the party and was invited in by a friend with an extra ticket, lucky me. The bash, at IMG_5240The Second Floor on 6th and 30th, was elegand but relaxed, and I bumped into Peter immediately! Peter, who is now 80, let us know he was wearing the original tuxedo he wore in the movie — still fits! He was personable and seemed a little embarrassed by the attention. Charmingly, he didn't stop talking while being photographed. It was really excited to get to tell him and Larry how much their performances in the film meant to me.

We had a cringeworthy encounter not long after, when we spotted Mark Cuban. IMG_5244As my friend pounced on him for a photo, I realized it wasn't him, but a pretty great look-alike. The guy agreed to pose anyway, well aware of who people think he is. I asked him if he had any money and when he said no, I lost interest. We had better luck with strapping Zachary Levi, who told us he loved the play and was surprised how funny it was.

IMG_5213Best pic of the night? She's just exquisite. (Image by Mike Summers)

The photo ops at the party were plentiful, both for us and for the stars, who posed in every IMG_5215 permutation possible, including with each other, with Crowley, with Kramer, with some of the celebs in attendance and, of course, with my gaggle of gays.

Sarah Paulson was our first get, and what a stunner. She could not have been more game, and made sure to pose working her good side. She knows her angles, and they work with mine — my best pic of the night. She loved the play.

IMG_5223Matt Squared (Image by Mike Summers)

IMG_5224Plaid boy (Image by Mike Summers)

IMG_5226Boys (Image by Mike Summers)

The actors were mostly very, very nice, and for a change I had things to say other than asking f IMG_5222or a photo since I'm so familiar with the play and told them I'd seen the first preview as well as that evening's performance. Robin (best-dressed? I liked Charlie's look, too) was curious about differences I'd detected, and he told me the slight changes in some of his character Emory's dialogue were not his doing. Zachary Quinto was pretty ready to not pose with us, but I can't complain; I told him he was a most worthy Harold and I suspect and hope he knows it.

Matt Bomer, dazzling to look at, was interested in my observation that his IMG_5227 character, Donald, came off (thanks to him) as having more of an inner life than I'd noticed before. He also graced me with two photos when the first try resulted in no flash.

Jim Parsons is the lynchpin of the play and hurt his ankle not long ago, but he wasn't displaying any signs of feeling the pressure. He actually looked ... radiant?! ... seated (in order to rest the healing ankle) and, like Bomer, was keenly interested in my comments about his performance.

IMG_5233Tuc, yeah! (Image by Mike Summers)

IMG_5235The Carvers — collect all ...

IMG_5245... two of them! (Images by Mike Summers)

Tuc Watkins was the most relaxed out of everyone, so I was able to chat with him a bit longer. IMG_5236He expressed gratitude toward Larry Luckinbill, whom he said had made it clear he was passing the baton on the role he'd played. Watching Luckinbill hug him while wife Lucie sneaked iPhone pictures was so sweet. Watching Brian Hutchison chatting with Peter White as they discussed their (very different) Alans was also stirring.

Michael Benjamin Washington and Andrew Rannells were similarly kind. I was really wowed to discover that Andrew is so tall (as is everyone in the cast except for Robin, which works visually since Robin's character is a “chicken wing”). 

The Carver brothers are just so hard not to stare at. Max was there with Sarah Sutherland of Veep IMG_5231(told her how obsessed I am with that show and how much I love her character and she was humble and gracious), and both Max and Charlie were way indulgent with all the gay men seeking selfies. Max told me he was proud of Charlie, and he should be — Charlie's part is the smallest and some of his lines are barely written to be jokes, per se, but he gets big laughs with them all and a huge cheer on his exit line, which as written really isn't that funny.

IMG_5229Relieved he didn't shout at me to choose between Meryl Streep and Oprah (Image by Mike Summers)

It was also nice chatting with Taylor Frey (whose husband is Kyle Dean Massey, one of the play's understudies), whose GBF producer Stephen Israel is the lead producer of my upcoming Boy Culture: The Series. And Billy Eichner! He was super funny — I told him he should take over one of the parts and he haughtily said, jokingly, “I don't replace.”

It was a celebratory night, one I'm grateful not to have missed, and one that was a long time coming for a historically important and still relevant gay play.